Late this afternoon, Chris Charvella received word from his attorney that Town of Batavia Justice Mike Cleveland has dismissed the aggravated harassment, 2nd, charge he was arrested on in November.
E. Robert Fussell, Charvella's attorney, could not be reached for further information on the dismissal and the town court is closed at this hour, so we can't retrieve a copy of the decision.
Fussell told his client the charges were dropped because of insufficient evidence to support the charge.
"It shows that politicians at any level can't have a person arrested for saying something they don't like, especially, 'thank you,'" Charvella said.
He added, "I knew since I was arrested on November 11th that I had not committed a crime. I placed my trust in the justice system and I'm glad the system worked."
State Troopers arrested Charvella after Legislator Jay Grasso filed a complaint against Charvella claiming harassment.
Charvella was charged under a provision of the statute that prohibits telephone calls for "no legitimate purpose."
The call Charvella made was to Grasso's home phone, and he left a message that said, "thanks for reading my blog."
The message was in response to somebody leaving a political sign on Charvella's front lawn that made reference to an item Charvella posted on her personal blog. The sign contained the words, "Sharome Glasshole," a reference to one of Charvella's blog posts.
Following the phone call, Charvella posted another item on his blog that showed a picture of an Ewok and read, "prepare your anus."
Assistent District Attorney Melissa Cianfrini argued against Fussell's motion for dismissal on June 10.
Part of Fussell's position was that based on previous case law, the conduct of Charvella didn't rise to the level of aggravated harassment, 2nd, as intended by the statute since there wasn't an ongoing pattern of harassment. He characterized Charvella's speech as protected by the First Amendment.
Today, Charvella called the dismissal a victory for free speech.
Charvella has said previously that he spent $7,000 on his own defense in the case.
Neither Cianfrini nor Grasso were immediately available for comment.
Justice was a bit slow,
Justice was a bit slow, justice was a bit expensive, but justice was served. Thank you Judge Cleveland for ending this today.
Edited because there were so many judges I couldn't keep them all straight.
Congrats, Chris. It was a
Congrats, Chris.
It was a long time coming, but justice is served.
Yippeeeeee!
Yippeeeeee!
Glad to see this over.
Glad to see this over.
Great news!
Great news!
It's ridiculous that justice
It's ridiculous that justice costs $7000.
Time for a fund raising
Time for a fund raising event, I think.
Anyone have any ideas?
Bake sale? I love brownies --
Bake sale? I love brownies -- specifically brownie bites from Scratch Bakery.
Great news!
Great news!
Great news for Chris, good
Great news for Chris, good day for our system of justice.
Now go to Civil Court and
Now go to Civil Court and counter sue on a contingency basis. If you can't find someone to represent you in WNY just watch one episode of Judge Judy and pay attention to the commercials.
I think your ewok suffered
I think your ewok suffered emotional damage too and is deserving of monetary compensation.
It's over. Now hopefully our
It's over. Now hopefully our political discourse will be about the issues.
Congrats Chris! So glad this
Congrats Chris! So glad this is over for you at last. I know you must be feeling light as air by now.
Hopefully you're next on the
Hopefully you're next on the "dismissed charges" list, Michele.
Good for you Chris. The whole
Good for you Chris. The whole thing was a waste of time and money. Glad to see you won't serve jail time for this.
Vindication: Feels god, man.
Vindication: Feels god, man.
Congratulations! Vindication
Congratulations! Vindication (however belated), sweet! 2011- the year two Democrats (Charvella and Hochul) derailed the status quo machine.