Whether girl was actually abducted remains in question

(Updated 7:09 p.m.)

The investigation is still in its preliminary stages, but a Batavia Police spokesman today acknowledged that police have yet to verify the story of a 14-year-old girl who says she was abducted as she walked to school on Washington Avenue this morning.

"We're trying to ascertain if this actually did occur, if there was something along the lines that she made this up for some reason," said Officer Eric Hill. "We don’t know for certain, which is why we have detectives out there (conducting interviews)."

The girl first reported the abduction to Batavia Schools' Superintendent Margaret Puzio.

Puzio said she believes the girl.

The girl wandered into Puzio's office about 10:45 a.m. saying that she had been abducted by a black man, 20 to 30 years old, wearing a black, long-sleeve shirt and blue jeans. She said the abduction occurred about 7:45 a.m. or 8 a.m. in the area of State Street and Washington Avenue.

Puzio contacted Batavia Police at 10:56 a.m.

The story the girl told Puzio, she said, is consistent with the story the girl told to police.

Why the girl wandered into the Washington Avenue location of the board of education, Puzio said she didn't know. She said she assumed the girl had walked by the building many times and knew what office it was.

“I assume she decided that was a safe place,” Puzio said.

Even though the location of the alleged intersection is a busy place that time of the morning -- it's part of the route many people might take to Batavia High School -- there are apparently no witnesses to the alleged abduction.

Investigators have been canvassing the area looking for more information, Hill said.

Hill said investigators have yet to determine how the alleged abductor got the girl into his minivan.

"That's not known at this point," Hill said. "That's a question for us at this point. We don't know what happened."

It's also unclear how the girl got away from her abductor. Hill said the detectives may have information he is not aware of, but said, "she reported to us that she got away. That's all we know, or, that's all I know."

Parents were notified of the alleged abduction some time before 2 p.m. through an automated call of a recorded message from Puzio.

Parents contacting The Batavian say the message did not contain information on the status of the girl or if her parents had been notified, causing them to panic about the safety of their own children.

Puzio said the message was well thought out and she consulted with the Batavia Police Department before deciding to send out a message through the automated call system.

"We always try to err on the side of giving as much information as we possibly can," Puzio said "We certainly deliberated over whether to say anything or not. What we decided to say is what we felt comfortable with."

Asked if she was concerned that fear from this incident would wind up encouraging parents to keep the children home from school tomorrow, Puzio said, "I hope not, but it’s always good to be reminded that students, your kids, are precious and sometimes we take for granted that they know not to go near cars with strangers in them, but sometimes it’s good to have something like this to reinforce that message."

Officer Hill said that if he had kids, he would consider driving them to school tomorrow, at least until this matter is resolved.

Hill said in his five years on the force, there have been no similar incidents in Batavia. He called this alleged abduction an "isolated incident."